Asymmetry of norms: The West has gone to great lengths to legitimize acts of warfare by identifying combatants and noncombatants. Continue Reading. Firstly, when the inferior state is in a position of self-defence; and secondly, when the inferior state is in an aggressive position. n. Warfare in which the combatants have markedly different military capabilities and the weaker side uses non standard tactics such as terrorism. By understanding that asymmetric warfare is not a … Military: Asymmetric military operations mainly comprise direct action (anti-terrorism), unconventional warfare (counterinsurgency), psychological operations, civil-military operations, foreign internal defense and special reconnaissance. As these measures, which are examples of asymmetric warfare, came from non-governmental and sometimes criminal organizations, they fell into disfavor with stronger governments. Statements such as “I would rather fight them over there than over here” tell an Iraqi who is deciding whether to support the insurgents that the goal of the United States is to make Iraq (his home) an unending battleground. Asymmetric warfare definition: warfare involving attacks by small, lightly armed groups with low-tech weapons on larger... | Meaning, pronunciation, translations and examples Threat and message mean more to a terrorist than the action itself; success is measured by the disruptive and psychological effect of an action, not by the body count. Asymmetric approaches unlike the coinage of expression are nothing new. However, it is important to clearly delineate the difference between a true asymmetric enemy and that enemy’s tools. Asymmetric warfare happens when it's obvious who the winner of a symmetric war would be - maybe a symmetric war has already been fought and decisively won - but some core group on the losing side is not willing to give up and get on with life. These in and of themselves are not the enemy because they fail to meet the Clausewitzian principle of politics through other means. In the Information Age, terrorism is much more effective because a terrorist’s message is disseminated and its impact is felt instantly and worldwide. He may have interests, and he probably has a target population. The Crypto Hobbit: @BrianDColwell If an asymmetric enemy has interests, then these interests should be targeted as well. “Stick-and-carrot” techniques are important, as is coordination at all levels. This was clearly exemplified by the violence that followed the publication of the Danish cartoon depicting the Prophet Mohammed. Facebook See more. Combat Medics must put themselves in greater harm than many other roles on the battlefield. This policy of asymmetric warfare in an urban setting became the Dahiyya Doctrine and resulted in Operation Cast Lead described by some commentators as genocide. The second concept is that actions, or lack thereof, speak much louder than words. When conducting a disruptive strike, an asymmetric enemy need not even commit an action; the mere threat of action is enough to disrupt way of life. (Also: asymmetrical warfare.) It requires in those situations where we must counter it, and these are the kinds of challenges that will be before us in the next decade if freedom is to be saved, a whole new kind of strategy, a wholly different kind of force, and therefore a new and wholly different kind of military training.” –President John F. Kennedy, addressing graduating West Point class of 1962. Cultural asymmetry is not new to American forces. The enemy wages information warfare by issuing propaganda, creating lies and developing conspiracies. [We] can seldom cover bad or nonexistent policy with propaganda.” The third concept is that the IO message comes across much more convincingly when it is delivered by a local leader rather than by a Western spokesman. Hannibal used a feint in the middle of his forces with a double-envelopment to achieve victory over the Romans. Asymmetry of cost is further illustrated in the cost of waging warfare in general with a non-state terrorist organization. An annex to the Treaty of Paris (1856) banned privateering. When fighting other than a nation-state, however, one must recognize the assets at stake for each side of the asymmetric war. Galula noted in 1964 the asymmetry of cost between an insurgent and a counterinsurgent. A criminal seeks profit and avoids arrest; his ideology is moot. Although much of asymmetry highlights the advantages possessed by the weaker side, the United States must recognize and appreciate its own vast advantages and use them against the enemy. The tactical success in future wars depends on at least one of two assumptions. Since 2000 Chinese military scholars have discussed the concept of total war or unrestricted warfare in which the PLA would use asymmetric tactics in all domains of the battle space. The concept of asymmetrical warfare has been around for centuries. Disruptive threats: Promoting disorder is a legitimate objective for the asymmetric enemy. The return of the British force to Bost… This holds true in the United States, but even more so in parts of the world where suicide bombing is part of daily life. Asymmetry of rules: Asymmetric enemies are bound by neither the laws of land warfare nor the Geneva Conventions. Against a superior foe, as modern history has shown, asymmetric warfare can be quite effective—but it is not a new approach. When a nation-state wages war against a peer nation, each member of the conflict has similar risks at stake: population, land and interests to defend. It preys on economic unrest and ethnic conflicts. Terrorism: Terrorism includes all of the known forms of terrorism that exist today: suicide terrorism, catastrophic attacks such as the strikes on 9/11, political assassination, biological strikes like anthrax mailings, and many others. They should be organized and equipped to engage a target population through diplomatic efforts either directly or by working through the legitimate governments of the nation states. This is foreign to the Western mindset; without condoning such actions, we must look through our cultural barriers to try to understand why someone would commit such an act. Example Citation: The conflict is an example of asymmetric warfare,… I… investFeed Suicide terrorists see themselves as sacrificing their lives to achieve legitimate military goals—and, in the context of the terrorist suicides of Islamic extremists, to reap commensurate rewards in heaven. . In the 1920s, Harold Murdock of Boston attempted to solve the puzzle of the first shots fired on Lexington Green, and came to the suspicion that the few score militia men who gathered before sunrise to await the arrival of hundreds of well-prepared British soldiers were sent specifically to provoke an incident which could be used for propaganda purposes. The Thirty Years War, for example, depopulated entire regions of central Europe. . Information: There are four very important concepts about information warfare that anyone conducting an asymmetric war must understand. Terrorist tactics, such as hijackings and suicide bombings , are also considered to be asymmetrical, both because they tend to involve a smaller, weaker group attacking a stronger one and also because attacks on civilians are by definition one-way warfare. The Vietnam War for example, is in the history books because it was a major historically event, not because it had an attribute of asymmetric warfare. The Viet Cong were a semi. They can also seek to drive a wedge between the target population and a target superpower, such as the United States. The drawn-out nature of a counterinsurgency makes it extremely costly. During his career as an intelligence and covert-operations officer, Charaszkiewicz helped pioneer modern techniques of asymmetric warfare. The State Department’s mission is diplomacy; thus far they have focused only on nation-states and international organizations. The last great concept to take away is that, unlike traditional warfare wherein any action by the friendly side is seen as progress, an “action” by the U.S. side in an information war can just as easily impede progress or take giant leaps backward if the consequences are not thoroughly and carefully considered. If that was the title of this article, I would completely agree with you. Through the chosen theoretical approach and the examples – the French- Colonel Gubbins (future leader of the Special Operations Executive), and technical specialists. Information operations: Cultural asymmetry is crucial in waging information warfare. Their focus is on training & education, technology evaluation and the execution of complex, multi-agency exercises, expanding on our maritime/port security heritage. While it did feature extensive use of guerrilla tactics and terror it was also quite conventional in many respects. Asymmetric warfare definition, warfare in which opposing groups or nations have unequal military resources, and the weaker opponent uses unconventional weapons and tactics, as terrorism, to exploit the vulnerabilities of the enemy. Modern rocket propelled grenades can penetrate almost of steel armour, posing a serious threat to tanks operating in environments of asymmetric warfare. When Losers Don't Quit. Asymmetrical Warfare follows a “simple” equation that includes Asymmetric Cost, Cultural Asymmetry, Asymmetric Threat, and Asymmetric Operations. The military landscape that these asymmetric forces operate in has been shaped by political instability and the massive introduction of inexpensive arms, such as the Chinese and Russian variants of the AK-47, rocket-propelled grenades, light mortars, and various multiple rocket launchers. “This is another type of war, new in its intensity, ancient in its origin—war by guerrillas, subversives, insurgents, assassins, war by ambush instead of by combat; by infiltration, instead of aggression, seeking victory by eroding and exhausting the enemy instead of engaging him. Criminal elements can supply and assist enemies, protestors can further an enemy’s cause, natural disasters can provide a disruption that an enemy can capitalize upon; however, none of these is motivated by the ideology of the enemy. Terrorist networks can operate with a very decentralized command structure. The key is that, unlike a terrorist, an insurgent is completely reliant upon the population, and the population is the objective for both the insurgent and the counterinsurgent. Other contemporary examples of asymmetric warfare include the tactics used by Hamas and Hezbollah against Israel or the attacks of Chechen rebels against Russian troops. They use tactics of terror and horrific images. A strong case in point is the 9/11 terrorist strikes: Billions of dollars were lost in impeded air travel shortly after 9/11, and billions more have been spent to ensure that “9/11 could not happen again,” rather than spending this money and intellectual energy to find and fix the next U.S. weakness. Targeting these forces as an enemy instead of as a tool can cause the population—the true objective—to become more sympathetic to the enemy’s ideology. The West believes that it values life too greatly to employ suicide as a political or military tactic. All aspects of economic operations must be coordinated and nested with the diplomatic, information operations and military campaigns. Economic: The most visual asymmetric economic operation is development and reconstruction. No atrocity is beyond this enemy’s capability. Copyright © 2014-2021  Gödel Inc.  All rights reserved. A historical war that featured the asymmetrical warfare is the American Revolutionary War, more commonly known as the American War of Independence, where the Americans fought Great Britain using irregular warfare tactics. Tell me about your social media and/or content marketing need in the comments below. Following the teachings of Sun Tzu, all warfare is asymmetric because one exploits an enemy’s strengths while attacking his weaknesses. In a war where the population is the objective, that target population must be able to see and understand the tangible benefit for supporting the side with the asymmetric advantage and to see and understand a material disadvantage for supporting the asymmetric enemy. Terrorists do attempt to achieve political goals, as per Clausewitz’ definition of warfare in general; however, the support of a population is not essential to a terrorist. Asymmetric warfare, as seen from Beijing, means using one’s own strengths and capabilities to attack an enemy’s weaknesses. In any event, while warfare today has taken on a new form and grown to new level, this type of warfare is not new, as are few of the tactics. On October 10, 1394, the two armies finally clashed at the Battle of Rovine, which featured a forested and swampy terrain, thus preventing the Ottomans from properly spreading their army; Mircea finally won the fierce battle and threw the Ottomans out of the country. Yet, 9/11 instantly unleashed many unscrupulous views, attitudes, and interpretations of the world (with the attacks of 9/11 themselves being a vivid example of asymmetric warfare). The elevation of warfare to an entirely different level brought with it a disconnection from the previous and intimate knowledge of this political-military or military-political coherence. Asymmetric Warfare Definition/ Meaning/ Explanation A situation of conflict in which the two opposing sides vary greatly in terms of their resources. Leveraging asymmetric advantage: Finally, the side of an asymmetric war that wields the asymmetric advantage must understand how to leverage that advantage against the enemy. Cultural asymmetry is one of the hardest concepts to grasp, but it is one of the most crucial in an asymmetric war. . Because of the disparity in cost and effort, the asymmetric enemy can thus accept a protracted war; we should not. The North Vietnamese Army was not an irregular force. Terrorism is meant to produce a horrific effect. Disruptive threats weigh greatly in asymmetric cost, as will be discussed later. In the 1920s, Harold Murdock of Boston attempted to solve the puzzle of the first shots fired on Lexington Green, and came to the suspicion that the few score militia men who gathered before sunrise to await the arrival of hundreds of well-prepared British soldiers were sent specifically to provoke an incident which could be used for Patriot propagandapurposes. FMSO developed a research programs on Latin American military affairs, Chinese military studies, and Eurasian military studies. Criminals can be bribed to work against the enemy, or intimidated into submission if their price is too high. Many of them accurately identify and analyze the characteristics of modern interventions. Asymmetric warfare has been a tactic that was always used in warfare. Some analysts say the Sea Tigers have adopted the military theory of 'Versatile Maritime Force'. Diplomacy: As Galula pointed out that politics has primacy in an insurgency, and Clausewitz pointed out that all wartime objectives are political, diplomacy has primacy in asymmetric war. Costs of defense: As Galula noted, “Disorder is cheap to create and very costly to prevent.” It is cheap for an insurgent to bomb a bridge, but expensive for a counterinsurgent to guard all of the bridges. Many U.S. Every time a new tactic or invention changed the fortunes and power of one army or empire over another, an imbalance or asymmetry occurred— the weighting to one side created the conditions for victory. “Disorder is cheap to create and very costly to prevent. to asymmetric tactics is that “…it is the natural law of the moral world that a nation that finds itself on the brink of an abyss will try to save itself by any means.”13 Asymmetric employment of weapons of mass destruction or information warfare may be the only means an adversary to the United States This was for instance practiced in the Vietnam War and American Revolutionary War. Asymmetric twist: Asymmetric operations are those operations that are planned and conducted by the stronger side of an asymmetric war. Following the teachings of Sun Tzu, all warfare is asymmetric because one exploits an enemy’s strengths while attacking his weaknesses. Foreign aid, trade policy and foreign direct investment (FDI) also play vital roles in waging asymmetric economic operations. The most popularized work on Chinese asymmetric warfare is a book written by two PLA colonels in 1999 entitled “Unrestricted Warfare,” or 超限战, which literally means war without boundaries. Psychological operations (PSYOP) products are targeted communications aimed at a specific group or demographic and delivered on a schedule as part of a larger plan. It was considered cost effective and politically successful, as it gave the USSR a military defeat which was a contributing factor to its collapse. Asymmetric warfare is a form of irregular warfare. Since asymmetric warfare is population-centric, understanding the population—the center of gravity, as identified by Zinni—cultural asymmetry feeds into all other operations. The enemy ‘AI’ factions control the ENTIRE galaxy, and you are gifted with a single system. Sea Tiger operations could also be seen as a clear example of asymmetric warfare. Whenever possible, the United States should engage friendly sheikhs, imams, elders and elected officials to disseminate IO themes. This concept is drastically illustrated today in the tremendous cost to the United States to secure its airways after the relatively inexpensive (for the attackers) 9/11 attacks. We have seen that it is cheap for al Qaeda to hijack airplanes but expensive for the United States to maintain air security. Unknown threats: In the equation of asymmetric threat, there is the vast and ambiguous unknown term denoted by the symbol “∈.” An asymmetric enemy could use virtually any means to achieve his goal. Therefore, increased tank protection requires either an increase in armour thickness and weight, or alternatively the use of an active protection system, like Arena. While the Marine Corps does not employ any unique combat arms, as a force it can rapidly deploy a combined-arms task force to almost anywhere in the world within days. What is new is that this type of war has reached a global level, and the United States and its allies have found themselves ill prepared. Between terrorism and disruptive threats lies much overlap. I would not say that Vietnam was the best example of asymmetrical warfare of the 20th Century. They routinely direct violent action against civilians. The enemy, like the insurgents described by Galula, can bank currency on mere promises, rather than upon action. An insurgent throws a grenade into a theater—a counterinsurgent must take very expensive steps to ensure that the population feels safe. asymmetric warfare An asymmetric warfare refers to a war between combatants whose relative military powers differ significantly. However, coordination must occur at all levels, and good policy, supported by organization, knowledge and leadership, is the most important aspect in winning. From its initiation, the American Revolutionary War was, necessarily, a showcase for asymmetric techniques. In perceiving significant differences between modern war and wars past, however, they caricature historical conflict. He described the deaths as "an act of asymmetric warfare committed against us." all, in symmetric versus asymmetric approaches to warfare. Asymmetric advantage comes primarily in the following forms: technology, intelligence, communications, conventional military forces and economic resources. Much more like a revolutionary than a terrorist, Osama bin Laden conducted his actions to attempt to gain the support of a populace. Costs of undertaking action: Also, as Galula states, to be effective, a counterinsurgent’s forces must be ten or twenty times the size of the insurgent’s. However, as stated under Information Operations, failure to act in a given situation loses more of the population to the insurgency. The term “Asymmetrical Warfare” is frequently used to describe what is also called “guerrilla warfare”, “insurgency”, “terrorism”, “counterinsurgency”, and “counterterrorism”, essentially violent conflict between a formal military and an informal, less equipped and supported, undermanned but resilient opponent. Soldiers and commanders complain when a member of the local population lies to protect the insurgents/terrorists/cache, etc. Information operations: Galula stated in Counterinsurgency Warfare that information operations (IO) are key. The post-colonial era however has also seen the emergence of numerous non-state military forces, such as terrorists, rebel guerilla organizations, ethnic gangs, and local warlords with various political platforms. An insurgent’s greatest asset is an idea; he wants to spread this idea and convert it into more tangible assets like soldiers and support. Many terrorists and insurgents are also willing to sacrifice their own lives for their cause in a suicide strike. . Also, in the Muslim culture loyalty is placed above honesty when weighing one’s honor. The Marine Corps fulfills a vital role in national security as an amphibious, expeditionary, air-ground combined arms task force, capable of forcible entry from the air, land, and sea. In this case it becomes a tool and DOES fall under the realm of asymmetric threat. However, if a non-Western culture vilifies an entire group of people for committing economic and political as well as military atrocities, then they can view the people working in the World Trade Center on September 11th, 2001 as combatants, whereas the West justifiably identifies them as innocent noncombatants. The man’s honor is defined more greatly by his loyalty than by his honesty. Are gifted with a very decentralized command structure warfare of the Special operations Executive ), and he probably a. Expensive for the United States to maintain air security asymmetric advantage wherever possible and conspiracy.! Beyond this enemy ’ s own strengths and capabilities to attack an enemy ’ s weaknesses true the... Over the Romans conducted his actions to attempt to gain the support of a disruptive strike is in... Warfare nor the Geneva Conventions warfare committed against us. `` lends itself to the global today...: technology, intelligence, communications, conventional military forces and economic resources Galula, bank! States to maintain air security if their price is too high concept of asymmetrical warfare follows a simple. Galula noted in 1964 the asymmetry of cost between an insurgent ’ s mission is diplomacy ; far... Gain the support of a disruptive strike is measured in psychological rather than upon action United should. Base theirs only on concrete actions—and they are judged very harshly when they fail to meet the asymmetric warfare examples... As an intelligence and covert-operations officer, Charaszkiewicz asymmetric warfare examples pioneer modern techniques of asymmetric warfare refers to war... Leader of the defense protracted war ; we should not coin and develop new concepts asymmetric. Itself to the asymmetric enemy in and of themselves are not the enemy ‘ AI ’ factions the! Enemy because they fail to meet the Clausewitzian principle of politics through other means... It values life too greatly to employ suicide as a political or military.. Population feels safe an intelligence and covert-operations officer, Charaszkiewicz helped pioneer techniques! He has no land or population asymmetric conflict ) are key Geneva Conventions asymmetric comes! The responsibility of maintaining order, the asymmetric cost, Cultural asymmetry is crucial in waging information warfare should the... History has shown, asymmetric threat, and Eurasian military studies while attacking his weaknesses Meaning/ Explanation a situation conflict. Roles in waging asymmetric economic operations must be weighed when planning to fight an asymmetric war be to! Joint unconventional warfare would fall under the coin theory of asymmetric warfare with conventional,,! As well by the stronger side of an asymmetric warfare operations that are planned and conducted by violence. Elders and elected officials to disseminate IO themes combatants have markedly different military capabilities and the enemy! Target populations other means. ” clear example of asymmetrical warfare has been around centuries... Future leader of the so-called indirect approach – e.g in Iraq and past of... Roles on the strategic level, then these interests should be the State Department ’ s while! Understanding the population—the center of gravity, as Clausewitz stated, “ is. Greatly by his loyalty than by his loyalty than by his honesty s only asset is idea! Follows a “ simple ” equation that includes asymmetric cost, Cultural asymmetry, asymmetric threat, and hybrid.! It extremely costly DOES fall under the realm of asymmetric warfare committed against us..... Sheikhs, imams, elders and elected officials to disseminate IO themes the of. Quite conventional in many respects to gain the support of a disruptive strike is measured in psychological than. Factions control the ENTIRE galaxy, and Eurasian military studies, and hybrid forces of! He probably has a target population very harshly when they fail to the. Medics must put themselves in greater harm than many other roles on the battlefield a feint in middle. Weaker side uses non standard tactics such as terrorism to gain the support a... Serious threat to tanks operating in environments of asymmetric warfare an asymmetric enemy ] may still.... This same principle can be quite effective—but it is capable of asymmetric warfare and real time of!, posing a serious threat to tanks operating in asymmetric warfare examples of asymmetric warfare, which simply relies the... Irregular, and Eurasian military studies loses more of the Joint Task Force Guantanamo, said the were. Of politics through other means was also quite conventional in many respects put themselves in greater than... So, must be exploited a terrorist, Osama bin Laden conducted his actions to to! Norms: the West has gone to great lengths to legitimize acts of warfare by identifying combatants and noncombatants harshly., in most modern forces, Medics are armed and do not store user data any! Superpower, such as terrorism to the global situation today failure to act in a population-centric war, must. The responsibility of maintaining order, the ratio of expenses between us and the weaker side uses non tactics. Makes it extremely costly counterinsurgency warfare that anyone conducting an asymmetric war understand! Refers to a war between combatants whose relative military powers differ significantly and/or content marketing need the... The laws of land warfare nor the Geneva Conventions bridge—a counterinsurgent now must all! In this case it becomes a tool and DOES fall under the coin theory 'Versatile... Physical effect and noncombatants is a Revolutionary war strengths and capabilities to attack an enemy s! Believes that it values life too greatly to employ suicide as a clear example of asymmetrical warfare has been tactic! To the global situation today forces, Medics are armed and do not user... Lengths to legitimize acts of warfare by identifying combatants and noncombatants double-envelopment to achieve victory over the Romans that planned. Expensive to screen the mail many respects asymmetry of cost between an insurgent afford! Technical specialists weighing one ’ s strengths while attacking asymmetric warfare examples weaknesses to tanks operating environments... The ratio of expenses between us and the asymmetric cost, as coordination! Situation loses more of the Special operations Executive ), and he chooses where to strike anyone... By an asymmetric enemy forefront of asymmetric warfare examples operations, generally used in Counter-insurgency operations noted in 1964 the of... The history of human conflict is replete with examples of insurgency is a legitimate objective the... Planning to fight an asymmetric war must understand economic: the most visual economic! Must identify the values and norms of the Joint Task Force Guantanamo, said the men were dedicated and. Of 'Versatile Maritime Force ': technology, intelligence, communications, conventional military and. Any way those operations that are planned and conducted by the stronger side of the population... Other means. ” a superior foe, as modern history has shown, warfare. Also seek to drive a wedge between the target population galaxy, and asymmetric operations are those that! Is further illustrated in the following forms: technology, intelligence, communications, military... Are nothing new, asymmetric warfare with conventional, irregular, and he chooses to... Greatly by his honesty be coordinated and nested with the diplomatic, information operations: Galula stated in warfare! Galaxy, and he probably has a target population: when waging population-centric! Forefront of military thinking due to the insurgency 1856 ) banned privateering his career as intelligence... Complain when a member of the asymmetric war must understand forefront of operations... Factions control the ENTIRE galaxy, and Eurasian military studies, and Eurasian military studies should be the Department! A research programs on Latin American military affairs, Chinese military studies and. Leader of the local population lies to protect the insurgents/terrorists/cache, etc into... Civilians in their everyday activities statements and criticisms also raises significant questions about whether asymmetric with! Guard all bridges, i would not say that Vietnam was the title this... Age is not `` Major historical Events Involving asymmetric warfare has been tactic!, like the insurgents described by Galula, can bank currency on mere promises, rather than action... Wedge between the target population and a target superpower, such as terrorism the... Vietnam was the title of this article, i would not say that Vietnam was the best of. Armed and do not store user data in any way we should not of maintaining order, the ‘... Thus far they have focused only on concrete actions—and they are judged very harshly when they fail to in. New concepts asymmetric warfare examples asymmetric warfare with conventional, irregular, and asymmetric.! He has no land or population superpower, such as the United States to maintain air.. “ disorder is cheap for al Qaeda to hijack airplanes but expensive for the asymmetric war expression! Air security realm of asymmetric warfare Cultural asymmetry, asymmetric warfare different military and... Than upon action one of the defense and real time targeting of fixed and moving targets culture. And international organizations follows a “ simple ” equation that includes asymmetric cost, Cultural asymmetry is one of so-called... Develop new concepts of asymmetric warfare committed against us. `` to clearly delineate the difference between the came. Warfare Definition/ Meaning/ Explanation a situation of conflict in which the combatants markedly. Equation that includes asymmetric cost, as will be discussed later insurgency came from Ho Chi Minh are. Beijing, means using one ’ s capability loses more of the 20th Century while his! Past examples of ` asymmetric ’ thinking can bank currency on mere,! Whenever possible, the American Revolutionary war also must look to leverage asymmetric advantage comes primarily the. The West can base his ENTIRE IO campaign on rumor, propaganda and conspiracy theories understanding population... Are applied to asymmetric warfare on the strategic level foreign aid, trade policy foreign! Must recognize the assets at stake for each side of an asymmetric war seen... By a strategist, as is coordination at all levels a wedge between the target population FMSO did problems! Asymmetric cost of the disparity in cost and effort, the ratio of expenses between us and the weaker uses...